Kirby wins tickets to a video game convention but can't decide on whether he should take Fish or Eli. To help make his decision, he envisions how the day might go with each of them. Dawn also takes part in the convention when she lands a job dressing up as a comic-book character.

Someone is defacing school property with cartoon murals and signing them with Kirby's name, getting him in trouble at school. Kirby and Dawn team up to solve the case.