The gang moves into Infeld's beach house and Peter is quick to pursue their beautiful neighbor, Charlie. Jared and Peter must prove a veteran is alive after a clerical error wrongfully pronounced him deceased and he is poised to lose his house. Karp is increasingly concerned about Infeld's erratic behavior, which comes to a head when he befriends a Ukrainian drive-through worker and plans to marry her for a visa extension so she can pursue the American dream.

Wager is made between Rachel and the boys as to whose case will garner better PR for the firm -- Jared and Peter's defense of a fisherman in which they invoke "Pirate Law" or Rachel's case, a wrongful termination involving a self-proclaimed psychic. Meanwhile, Peter and Jared acquire a "discarded" curbside sofa, which Pindar discovers is a certain celebrity. This renews a feud between the star and their landlord, Stanton.