A middle school art teacher is shot to death in the home she shared with her husband; new evidence and testimonies poke holes in the story of a harmonious three-way affair between the couple and a mutual friend. 

Kansas couple Mike Sisco and Karen Harkness are found dead by their parents before a family fish fry in 2002. A years-long search for evidence and three criminal trials over two decades reveal strained dynamics within one victim's family.

INTERVIEWS WITH: Mike Sisco's mother Carol Sisco, daughter Hailey Seel, sister Cathy Boots and brother-in-law Mark Boots; Karen Harkness' daughter Erin Harkness Sutton and son Chad Harkness; Fmr. Topeka police Sgt. Richard Volle; Shawnee County District Attorney Mike Kagay; and others.