Host Joel McHale is joined by contestants Heather Sanford (hometown: Bakersfield, California), a pastor and Gretchen Frazier (hometown: Los Angeles, California), an executive assistant, in addition to Ashley Ruiz (hometown: Las Vegas, Nevada), an army veteran and Tim Kimura (hometown: Milpitas, California), an experience designer.

Host Joel McHale is joined by contestants Joy Cacayorin (hometown: Honolulu, Hawaii), an exercise instructor and David Delgado (hometown: Ashland, Oregon), a program manager, in addition to Michael Kearney (hometown: Okinawa, Japan), serving in the airforce and Keren Sheridan (hometown: Deer Park, New York), a traveling day-camp manager.