Some criminals make for very unusual suspects. First, a congregation is devastated by the murder of a rabbi's wife, only to find out one of their own is suspected. And next, grandmother, Doris Payne lives the double life as an international jewel thief.

Sydney Biddle Barrows, aka New York's "Mayflower Madam," is running a secret high-end escort service, and trying to stay one step ahead of authorities. Then Big Apple socialite Joy Silverman is stalked by a mystery man, leading to a FBI sting operation.