Tyler and Hadley encourage the creation of a senior superlatives-themed award show in a cunning play to highlight the in-crowd's elitism. "Superlatives" hosts Chad and Debra find themselves blindsided by a wave of populist resentment that results in the creation of highly individualized, "alternative yearbooks." A brand-new, dark horse candidate for Student Body President emerges.

While en route to prom, Hadler are summoned into Chadebra's limousine for a private chat. The opposing teams argue over who should get credit for Berenger's new "universal prom," and differ on the dangers posed by the candidacy of Blair McGunty. Tyler and Hadley seek political advice from a former co-worker and rival.