Rick and the Pawn Stars end up having the last ho-ho-ho when they catch Chum staging a sneaky Secret Santa. Next, will Rick go dashing through the snow in an 1800's one-horse open sleigh? And later, will Corey and Chum score a classic Lionel train set or have they bitten off more than they can choo-choo?

A man comes in with a Colt .45 he claims was used to kill Jesse James; an antique professional gambler's toolkit; a business card of the infamous gunfighter John Wesley Hardin.