Hilary and David revisit one of their favorite challenges that involved keeping a couple close to their sought-after community. Although David's choice earned him a coveted List It, they're eager to see how life in William and Ashley's new house is going.

Hilary loves to chide David whenever she wins a tough challenge, especially when her design decision was so hotly debated. They catch up with Don and Quincy to see if sacrificing a garage in favor of more living space gave them what they needed.