Homeowners Andrew and Nancy bought a converted triplex in a great neighborhood. They soon discovered the problems the conversion caused with functionality. Andrew has worked in their home to improve the aesthetics of the home, but the lack of functionality remains. Designer Hilary and her team come in to transform their home into a space they can use. At the same time, realtor David shows the couple homes that meet their needs. After the renovations in their home, and seeing other listings, Andrew and Nancy must decide what to do with their home. Should they Love It? Or List It?

Steve and Jennifer bought a 90-year-old fixer-upper for its location near Steve's family. Half-done renovations and multi-purposed rooms have the couple frustrated with their home. Designer Hilary and realtor David are ready to help the couple with their home issues. Hilary and her team will transform the home to be their dream home. Meanwhile, David will show them what they could have in a new home. In the end, Steve and Jennifer will have to choose which house works best for what they need.