As the snow returns to Vermont, the Winter House crew arrives to heat things up. While Kyle and Amanda enjoy their newlywedded bliss, Luke quickly becomes mesmerized by a new girl in the house. Reality sets in for Paige when, after living with Craig for two weeks, the house dynamic explodes at a costume party.

After a heated argument, one housemate remains in exile. Paige grows frustrated with Craig's behavior. Kory's attraction to one of the housemates starts to grow stronger. Jason still struggles to read Rachel as the group gets to know each other better through a round of speed dating. Austen arrives in the middle of chaos and quickly learns from Ciara that all his sins may not be forgiven.