Peter challenges Joe to a fight, winner gets Kelly. Joe refuses but Peter hits him anyway. Joe knocks him out and later Peter tells Kelly Joe started it. Cruz starts to confront Santana about copying Sophia to impress CC. Joe begs Kelly to keep the ring he bought for her five years ago. They kiss.

Ted and Laken tell their parents they want to move in together. Peter tells Kelly she has to choose between him and Joe. Santana tells Cruz about a gazebo where she and Channing used to meet. He thinks their love letters may be hidden there.