The campmates are thrown back in the freezing lake to retrieve buoys for cash, and then must play a awkward game where their true feelings about one another are shared out loud; each camper reveals who they believe to be the killer.

The campmates vote one last time for who they think is the killer amongst them; events come to a head as two campers clash about the clues they've received and make a final play to convince fellow campers of their innocence.