Taylor is transported to a nightmarish version of Rock Island where she doesn't exist, and her friends don't know her. With her presence rapidly destroying the alternate world she must win the trust of these old friends in order to save it.

On the anniversary of Uncle Charlie's disappearance, the gang are shocked to see the Bermuda Queen flying over the island. But when their investigations lead them to a hidden airstrip, Taylor and Lila accidentally get trapped on a perilous flight.