All hope seems lost when Joey and friends are captured by the Killer Clowns. The group learns they must restore the Carnival Master's wicked artifacts to free the town—a mission that will require two to undertake a battle to the death.

A dead body is tossed from the balcony, giving a clue about the third artifact. The YouTubers form two hunting parties, but the team that fails to recover the missing pieces must face off against the Man with No Name.