Pauly and Vinny pull the ultimate prank on 20 women who think they are on a celebrity dating show. While some women take it all in stride, others crack under the pressure.

Sparks fly when first kisses for Pauly and Vinny make it clear which women are the favorites. Pauly and Vinny duke it out for the chance to take some of the women out on a date. Someone unexpectedly leaves the house.