Ten eligible women selected by a blue-ribbon panel of matchmakers vie for a chance at love with mystery suitor Mike, a police officer from Bakersfield, California, in search of his soul mate. By the end of the night, Mike will propose to one of two remaining women. Then, the newly acquainted couple will trust fate and exit the stage possibly engaged to be married.

Ten eligible women selected by a blue-ribbon panel of matchmakers, including a familiar face from "The Bachelor" franchise, vie for the heart of Stephen, a mystery man who is ready to take a leap of faith to find the love of his life.