Jessica, Emma and Sara are smart, funny and mostly dateless. Emma is the exception; her and her girlfriend Julie are in a fun, new relationship. And on Sara's suggestion Jessica decides to join a LARPing club on campus to meet some of the university's most eligible bachelors.

After dating for some time Mike is under the impression him and his college girlfriend Kitty are exclusive, until he walks in on Kitty making out with someone else in his own dorm room.