When respected pastor A.B. Schirmer's wife dies in a tragic car accident, the small Pennsylvania community mourns. But when a congregant commits suicide in the pastor's office, red flags are raised exposing a lurid affair. The pastor's inappropriate behavior and suspicious past sparks another investigation into the death of his first wife. Driven by friends and family members of the victims, a determined detective begins a crusade for justice.

A young father is found with a fatal gunshot wound. The authorities say it's suicide but his family knows he would never take his own life. A mother and daughter fight for nearly 40 years to reveal the truth with the help of a dedicated police chief.