Catching a Catcher is a Making A Murderer parody that explores the story of Doug Dripp (JB Smoove), a minor league catcher who has attempted for almost 20 years to tag out Terry Staubach, an opponent he claims never touched home plate while scoring the winning run in the World Series. However, when Terry Staubach is murdered and Doug is accused of the crime, he sets out to prove his innocence and Minor League Baseball's agenda to frame him.

The story of the rise and fall of J.D. Dunst (Amir Blumenfeld). Regarded as the greatest coin flip guesser in the world and having never played football, Dunst was signed by the San Diego Chargers primarily to win opening coin flips, and more importantly, the coin flips that decided who gets the ball to start sudden death overtime. We follow him from his rapid rise to fame through his eventual downfall, brought upon by a devastating gaffe where prior to overtime in the 2005 AFC Championship game, he accidentally called "teads".