Ryan takes his team to Point Pleasant, West Virginia to investigate his own personal holy grail of paranormal lore: the mysterious Mothman. Is this winged creature an alien intent on our destruction, or a harbinger sent to warn us of impending doom?

PRS checks into the Knickerbocker Hotel in Linesville, Pennsylvania where the owners are reporting strange noises and the appearance of phantom children in some of the rooms. Ryan and the crew invite psychic C.J. Sellers to help them.