Sixteen-year-old Judy Rawlings vanished in 2001 after a midnight ride with a friend, her body found hidden in the woods weeks later. Does her friend know more than he's told police? Could someone in this small town hold the key to solving her murder?

Twenty-three-year-old Codi Joyce ends up dead after a brawl at a house party in 2015, yet nobody has been charged for his death, and witnesses won't talk.