When a pastor loses a second wife in an accident, authorities become suspicious. Dennis Murphy returns to this unforgettable story of evil and betrayal, wondering how far this a man of God might have fallen. Dennis still can't believe the answer.

After a 15-year-old girl disappears, investigators discover a creek where the local teenagers hang out. This hideaway may hold answers. Dennis Murphy looks back on the case that kept him guessing until its astonishing conclusion.