Garage sale guru Jennifer Shannon discovers a dead body in the storage locker she and business partner Dani have purchased at auction. When further inspection of the locker's contents includes plaster "death masks," and one of those masks perfectly matches the dead woman's visage, Jennifer's "inner sleuth" kicks into overdrive as she pieces together the clues that will lead to the killer.

When a local art collector dies and his expansive collection is auctioned off, garage sale guru and amateur sleuth Jennifer Shannon and business partner Dani purchase a rare piece. However, when the provenance of the entire collection comes into question, and Jenn determines that the man may have a secret stash of ill-gotten treasures hidden away, she finds herself investigating a pre-meditated murder.