The survivors hold an election for island leader to see who has the best plan to deal with the tyrannical Todd. Meanwhile, Todd challenges Danny to a drink-off: the hidden community pile for Danny's gun.

When Danny accidentally shoots Pack after Pack returns from his jungle sojourn, Steve calls a trial to determine Danny's punishment. Meanwhile, Emma diagnoses Yolonzo with Red Death, and Jess tries to get over Todd by having sex with Chet.