After a night of confrontations and one broken glass, the ladies come back home to NJ with a clear division between the group. As Margaret prepares for her Hospital Heroes event, Melissa continues to search for answers about her father, and Jackie's decision to reconcile with her sister comes to a head. The group looks to find its footing as Melissa, Margaret, and Dolores all try to convince Teresa that Danielle is no good.

Part one of the reunion kicks off when Margaret and Jennifer enter a heated game of words when they address their ongoing conflict this season. Jackie is in the hot seat when Teresa accuses her of having ulterior intentions about joining the show and makes it clear that she will never forgive what Jackie said about her husband.