The OC ladies come face-to-face for a dramatic reunion. Shannon and Tamra hash out their conflicting versions of events following Shannon's DUI. Heather confronts Katie on the paparazzi rumors before teaming up with Emily and Gina to grill Katie about recent shocking headlines, forcing Katie to defend her past. Jenn is placed in the hot seat when the group brings up details of the FBI investigation involving her fiancé, Ryan.

The reunion concludes with a heated faceoff between Shannon and Alexis as they discuss discrepancies in the lawsuit with John Janssen and their dating timelines. Emotions run high as Tamra and Shannon discuss the future of their friendship. The ladies react to unseen footage of John's interview where he opens up about his relationship with Shannon.