Investigating strange events at a nearby campsite, Mitch and Ryan enter a cabin and find themselves transported back in time to a 1890's brothel in New York with an ax/knife wielding killer planning to murder everyone involved

Mitch investigates the disappearance of two Baywatch lifeguards without a trace in the water going after cries of drowning. When Donna also goes missing, Mitch investigates an old auto accident with one survivor who may hold a clue to the disappearances.