Laura and Nico, devastated at their failure so far in stopping the city's serial killer, set a trap for him that puts both of them in danger. Meanwhile, Tom becomes worried about Nico and Laura's partnership, since Tom was the attorney who convicted Nico's brother Danny,

Laura thinks Tom is lying to her, so she enlists Nico to follow him; Laura and Nico return to Spanish Harbor to investigate how their fates are intertwined.