Laura thinks Tom is lying to her, so she enlists Nico to follow him; Laura and Nico return to Spanish Harbor to investigate how their fates are intertwined.

Laura convinces Nico that they need to find the fourth man from the tattoo photo; while doing so, they learn more about the case 10 years ago against Danny. Also, Laura gives Tom a chance to explain his actions and must decide whether she - and Serena - can trust him.