Frank is called in to find a murderer who sent his victim's wife his severed tongue. Frank thinks the murders are connected to other unexplained serial killings where body parts were also sent through the post. Soon Frank comes to realize that the serial killers are being recruited by a man calling himself 'The Judge', who has a satanic way of dealing out justice...

A desperate man sets out on a killing spree taking revenge on the holy men that he believes have led him to stray. Frank can see the man's sense of faith and the lack his faith could be the key to stopping this killer. Frank then puts himself in danger when he walks into a hostage situation at a small town church.