On their anniversary, Karen and Jeff get together with Karen's parents for dinner. Jeff has problems with his father in-law so Karen talks him into going fishing with her dad. Jeff's father in-law then tells Jeff a secret about his past that Jeff did not want to know after having a few beers. Meanwhile, Jeff sends the guys to Victoria's secret at the local mall to repair the stores air conditioning system.

Jeff and Elliot look for a glass of milk, straight from the cow when they team up for a Halloween scavenger hunt.