Buddy lays down a ghoulish gauntlet as sibling teams bake and decorate their spookiest Halloween cakes; Buddy's two favorite witches, his sister Grace and "Next Great Baker" Marissa Lopez, join him on judging all the gory details.

Once upon a time, at a test kitchen in New Jersey, Buddy challenged two mother daughter teams to make imaginative Fantasy Cakes. But, if they want to have a fairy tale ending, they'll need to impress Buddy, Carlo's toughest critic Mary, and best sculptor Ralph.