After bouncing around from one rental disaster to the next, a couple is ready to find a first home that's as quirky as they are, and the Property Brothers are determined to make it happen. During the house hunt, Drew manages to find a low-priced gem in a red-hot neighborhood, but that's when their luck runs out. With a slew of nasty surprises, Jonathan struggles to stay on top of the schedule and budget while balancing their very eccentric style.

After years of moving around the country, Lesli and Dave are ready to call Nashville home. Drew leads the hunt for a fixer-upper with potential to be a forever home, but the couple must decide whether to go for their lakefront dream or stay closer to the city. Later, Jonathan must keep Lesli calm as the budget takes a series of hits, and then he hustles to finish in time for Dave's neighborhood housewarming party.