When unemployed brothers Mark and Hank Hoagies go deer hunting to try their new high-tech crossbow, they run into Doug, one of their former friends who is also secretly a murderer. As Doug tries to discreetly kill Mark and Hank, Mark accidentally murders him with the crossbow while hunting a deer, forcing Mark and Hank to decide what to do next. Meanwhile, Mark's neighbor David is a proclaimed vegetarian struggling to keep deer from eating his garden.