The gang is in deep trouble after a prank they pull on Becky Snyder goes horribly wrong. Meanwhile, Dusty sends a target on a roller coaster ride while posing as a popular mascot for an Italian restaurant, and Bailey and Herman trick a target into believing he has uncovered a buried treasure.

When Herman tries to do a prank on his own, he ends up trapped inside the school's trophy case. Now it's up to the rest of the gang to get him out without getting caught. Meanwhile, when Chance and Dusty show the babysitter their dad's archeology lab, they accidently turn on a high-tech laser security system with extra "security" reinforcement.