Chingachgook has a vision where in defense of Elizabeth, Hawkeye is shot in the back by an arrow. Elizabeth leaves the fort to help deliver the baby of a local woman whose husband is a colonial soldier. Unfortunately, a group of disgraced Delaware, who have been expelled from Chingachgook's tribe and are going about killing and stealing from colonials, surround the cabin. Despite the shaman's warning not to interfere with Hawkeye's destiny, Chingachgook goes to Elizabeth's aid and winds up injured. Hawkeye arrives in time to save the day, but thanks to Chingachgook's actions, Hawkeye doesn't die. Meanwhile, McKinney comes up with another get-rich-quick scheme involving a "miracle elixir".

On the way to visit his aunt Elizabeth, young Andrew sees two Hurons meeting with a white man, but he doesn't see his face. Adjusting to life at the fort is difficult for young Andrew, especially since the white man he saw wants him dead. Hawkeye teaches the young man how to fight to defend himself, a skill he'll need when the fort is attacked. Andrew changes his mind about his future.