A mysterious woman arrives at the fort during an epidemic with secrets and help, but will rumors of her fleeing the Salem witch trials cause trouble?

Elizabeth's missing husband, William, returns and everyone's lives will be affected. The torture he endured even as he gained the Huron's respect has addled his mind. Chingachgook is sure that William isn't safe. Taylor is at a loss, trying to cover up his misdeeds while Elizabeth and Hawkeye decide if they will tell William she wants to end her marriage or if she will stay with her husband.