After a young Texas teacher is found, in what appears to be a scene from a horror movie, having been axed to death on Friday the 13th, investigators work to uncover the truth behind a local church scandal in order to pin down a most unlikely suspect.

After the body of a teen is found at a local party spot, theories surrounding her death spread. Without evidence, the case goes cold for 30 years. When the investigation heats back up, authorities bring the killer to justice for not 1 but 2 murders.