A former ballerina fatally shoots her estranged husband in what she claims to be an act of self-defense. The case receives major media coverage after a history of questionable allegations and conflicting narratives come to light.

When body parts start turning up across New York, panic sets in over the possible return of a known serial killer. As detectives connect the dots, they uncover a simmering dispute that exploded into a crime far more disturbing than anyone imagined.