A nervous Hudson is taken in for questioning and cracks under pressure, revealing he didn't go straight home the night of the hit and run – he went to talk to his old coach, Don. When his alibi checks out, the police are back to square one with only a reconstructed note taken from Robbo's pocket to go on.

Mason is convinced Marty must somehow be involved in the hit and run on Robbo, but first he needs to rule out Amber's involvement. He demands to hear her version of events and after some coaxing, Amber finally confides what happened that night. Later, when Paul and Mason confront Marty, he denies any involvement in the hit and run.