After learning Terese reported Marty Kranic's hotel stay to the police, Paul goes into damage control. Afraid he will be implicated in the hit and run by association, Paul pays Marty to leave town. Meanwhile, Jack Lassiter returns to the hotel after his health scare but when he is unable to settle his previous room account, Paul discovers he has blown his vast fortune.

From the faces of all the prime suspects lined up at Lucas and Vanessa's wedding, we flashback through time and revisit the night of the hit and run, revealing events as they happened.