After Paige's outburst, Lauren is worried about Amber and Bailey. While Matt thinks Paige is playing games, Lauren asks Amber outright if she feels neglected. She says no but admits Bailey has had some issues and a concerned Lauren makes her reveal Bailey's secret. Lauren and Matt confront Bailey who claims to have only drunk once but they reveal they've searched his room and found a bottle.

Brennan is doing his best to move on, but when he encounters Paul seemingly without a care in the world, he becomes angry and frustrated and desires revenge. He goes to Matt and pressures him to re-open the Gus Cleary case with the aim of convicting Paul of murder. Matt doesn't feel this is possible without any new evidence but Brennan convinces him to question Paul again nonetheless.