Paige is reeling in the wake of Michelle's ultimatum that Paige and Tyler steal her a car to replace the one that Paige handed over to the police. She's further shocked when Tyler reveals his ongoing criminal connection with Michelle and her boss, and resolves to have nothing to do with Tyler or the theft of a car. But just when she thinks she's in the clear, Paige receives an anonymous text.

Paige is alarmed when she receives a text from Michelle demanding the stolen car money today. She debriefs with Tyler. They struggle for a solution, until he eventually claims he will fix this… somehow. Paige is left sceptical. Tyler offers to steal Michelle another car if she leaves Paige out of it. Michelle isn't interested because Tyler is too important to the operation now.