Paige is feeling humiliated after finding Tyler mid-tryst with a female customer at the garage. When a sheepish Tyler seeks out Paige to clear the air, Paige covers her humiliation and convinces Tyler that she had no intention of hooking up with him herself. But when Tyler discovers Paige's true motives for returning to the garage, tensions between them boil over.

Terese wants Susan to speak with Clem about Chloe but Susan thinks it is not her business… until Susan witnesses Clem tearing up his vintage cricket trading cards that Ezra bought him. Concerned, Susan calls Clem's ex-school principal and learns that this isn't the first time Clem has acted out. Susan probes and Clem lashes out at her, leaving Susan unsure what to do next.