Aaron goes into investigation mode after learning that Paul received a dead rat at the penthouse. Upon learning that Sheila was the person who took the mail up to Paul's apartment he confronts her. Sheila is insulted he'd think it was her, but she did see the culprit and is able to point him out to Aaron.

Steph is reeling from the revelation that Vanessa has been investigating her. And while Toadie is similarly taken aback, he convinces Steph they need to give Vanessa the chance to explain herself. Meanwhile, Sonya is not happy that her friend is being accused of harassing Steph, and indeed, when Vanessa arrives, she denies any wrong-doing.