Piper is shattered by Tylers confession, mainly because hes been sitting on the truth for so long, and even if he does prove to be innocent, Piper isnt sure that shell be able to forgive him. Mark is also irate about Tyler not coming forward sooner, but diligently sets about investigating the claim.

Nate reveals that he texted Julie Quill to test if she was the mystery texter but its not her. However, whoever it is has demanded ten grand to be placed in the old well that afternoon. Aaron is freaked, and Nate tries to comfort him with a kiss. In his vulnerable state, Aaron allows it, and it leads to more.