After Jack wakes up to find his fist bloodied, he struggles to remember what happened the night before. Recalling only that he saw Paige and Tyler kissing passionately, Jack worries that he injured his hand by beating up Tyler. Ashamed, Jack turns to Amy for help. She tracks down Tyler and Paige, relieved to see that Tyler is unharmed.

When Paige learns Amy is going to listen to Jack preach, she cant resist going along to hear him for herself. When Amy spots her, she advises Paige against it, as her presence might throw Jack off. Paige compromises by listening at the door, and she finds Jacks homily about love both inspiring and moving especially the part where he confesses to having experienced love recently.