Finns memory is returning, causing tension between David and Aaron who disagree on how to handle it. Karl, Susan, and Bea learn that Finn recognizes Harry Sinclair, while Gary is planning a surprise party for Amy. Kyle buys her an expensive present and Yashvi jokes about eating all the food, leaving Gary sweating.

Gary surprises Amy with a public proposal at her birthdaywedding party, but shes uncomfortable and takes him aside to explain that she cant marry him like this. Meanwhile, tensions rise between Terese and Leo over Vance, and Paul criticizes Sheilas son. Gary announces that the wedding wont happen and turns the celebration into an Amy birthday party.