Amy and Gary discuss an offer from Karl, weighing the pros and cons. Despite Garys hesitance, they decide to accept it. Kyle and Sheila encourage them to work together. Meanwhile, Andrea suggests contacting a friend from Heathers Spanish dancing class to find her, and Willow expresses concern for Andreas mental health.

Terese discovers that Pierce is buying a stolen horse from Vance and asks Ned to inform him to avoid any potential legal issues. Roxy enters and tells Terese about a fondue set she has purchased for Vance. Leo discovers the safe open with a note from Vance explaining he needed the cash for a quick getaway.