Chloe is struggling with her feelings for Nicolette, unsure if they are romantic or just gratitude for her support. Aaron warns her against telling Nicolette, but before they can finish their conversation, Nicolette interrupts. Meanwhile, Kyle, Roxy, and Sheila plan a memorial for Gary and Prue, inviting Harlow to join them.

Five friends gather to discuss a move made by Olivia, which could be seen as blackmail. They consider the possibility of getting the charges dropped, while Olivia is trying to convince Ned to paint a portrait for her book cover. She insists that she wants to tell the best story, no matter what.